All 6 carriers, reviewed.

Lemonade

Est. 2015

4.62

/5.00

#1

Lemonade ranks #1 for affordability among major renters insurance carriers, with average rates of $5 monthly.

State Farm

Est. 1922

4.42

/5.00

#2

State Farm is a renters insurance with the largest agent network and strong bundling discounts

GEICO

Est. 1936

4.35

/5.00

#3

GEICO ranks #2 for affordability among major renters insurance carriers, with average rates of $8 monthly.

Toggle by Farmers

Est. 2018

4.25

/5.00

#5

Toggle by Farmers is a modern renters insurance that lets you pay only for what you need with built-in identit

Progressive

Est. 1937

4.20

/5.00

#6

Progressive is a renters insurance with easy bundling, online quotes, and HomeQuote Explorer comparison

Allstate

Est. 1931

4.10

/5.00

#4

Allstate is a renters insurance with strong agent network and comprehensive coverage options