See auto rates

Last reviewed: May 20, 2026

Auto Insurance Review

Published: May 20, 2026Written byRai AntonioReviewed byDavid KrugData byFelix Lucero
Compare rates in your area

● Auto Insurance

Live auto rates from the carriers we've reviewed. Carriers pay us only when you switch.

Why trust QuoteYeti

QuoteYeti's editorial team has spent 30+ combined years researching insurance markets. Every piece is written by named writers, reviewed by our editor-in-chief against the QuoteYeti methodology, and rate-heavy content is verified by our data team. No paid placements. Read our editorial standards →

Acuity Auto Insurance Review

Acuity Insurance is one of those quietly excellent Midwest mutuals — consistently top-rated for customer satisfaction, available across 30 states, distributed through independent agents. It doesn't market heavily but it earns space on service depth.

Headquarters
2800 South Taylor Drive, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Website
www.acuity.com
Phone
833-242-5600

See live rates

Compare Acuity against the auto carriers we've reviewed.

Key takeaways

Acuity Insurance is a Wisconsin-based mutual with strong customer-satisfaction reputation.

— QuoteYeti editorial team
  1. 02 Available in 30 states, primarily Midwest and South.
  2. 03 Independent-agent distributed; competitive pricing in core markets.

Acuity ratings

Overall score
Customer experience 4.40/5
Coverage breadth 4.00/5
Affordability 3.80/5

Pros and cons

Ordered by impact. The top item in each column is the one we'd weight heaviest in a recommendation.

What's working

  • Top pro Consistently strong customer satisfaction reputation
  • Available in 30 states — broader than most Midwest mutuals
  • Independent agent distribution with state-specific expertise
  • Solid multi-line bundling discounts

What's not

  • Top con Limited brand recognition outside the Midwest
  • No online quoting — independent agents only
  • Mid-market pricing, not a budget option

Our verdict

The bottom line

Acuity is a quietly excellent choice in its 30-state footprint, particularly for buyers who value service over headline rates. Worth a quote in any of its operating states.
See auto rates Compare against our top auto carriers

Carriers pay us only when you switch

See what you'd actually pay for auto insurance.

You've read the Acuity review. Now compare it against the other carriers we cover — your real rate, not a marketing average.