Auto Insurance Review
Key takeaways
Motorist Mutual ratings
Scoring in progress
We're still in the field on Motorist Mutual. Their carrier reference page is here so you have what we have — verified company facts, our initial analysis, and the strengths and weaknesses we've identified — but their full editorial score, ranking, and cost benchmarking aren't ready yet. We don't post scores we haven't earned.
If you're comparing carriers right now, our full auto rankings covers the carriers we've scored.
Quick facts
- Headquartered
- OH
- Website
- encova.com/motorists-insurance-group-home/contact-us
- Phone
- 800-876-6642
From our prior coverage
What we've documented about Motorist Mutual
These notes are surfaced from QuoteYeti's prior coverage of Motorist Mutual. They aren't part of our v2 editorial scoring (which is still in progress) — we're showing them here so you have what we have. Some details may need updating; we'll refresh them when Motorist Mutual's full review is complete.
Motorist Mutual has earned its reputation on providing customers with dependable vehicle insurance backed by a reputable organization.
Motorists Mutual was formed in 1928 and is based in the wonderful city of Columbus, Ohio. Its financial strength rating–in other words, its ability to use money to protect your assets–is Excellent. On the other side, their J.D. Power rating, which assesses consumer satisfaction with regard to claims management, is Not Rated out of 5. A higher J.D. Power Rating indicates that a carrier will treat you favorably in the event of a claim.
Visit our review of Grange Mutual Auto Insurance Review for another car insurance review.
Pros and cons
Ordered by impact. The top item in each column is the one we'd weight heaviest in a recommendation.
What's working
What's not
Our verdict