Home  >  Reviews  >  Motorist Mutual Car Insurance Review

Motorist Mutual Car Insurance Review


Jeff Springer

Get a Quote

Ready to save hundreds on your car insurance?

Motorist Mutual Car

Motorist Mutual Car

471 East Broad Street, Columbus, OH 43215

QuoteYeti logic We collect and analyze millions of car insurance data points from the most trusted sources in the industry. The insights shown on this page represent an aggregate of car insurance ratings. We recommend using our information as a guide only. Individual results may vary.

Visit Website


Motorist Mutual has earned its reputation on providing customers with dependable vehicle insurance backed by a reputable organization.

About Motorists Mutual

Motorists Mutual was formed in 1928 and is based in the wonderful city of Columbus, Ohio. Its financial strength rating–in other words, its ability to use money to protect your assets–is Excellent. On the other side, their J.D. Power rating, which assesses consumer satisfaction with regard to claims management, is Not Rated out of 5. A higher J.D. Power Rating indicates that a carrier will treat you favorably in the event of a claim.

Ready to get started?

We’ve got you covered.

Motorists Mutual Auto Insurance Discounts & Features

  • Mobile Friendly
  • Pay Online
  • Report Claims Online
  • Towing & Labor
  • Rental Reimbursement
  • Transportation Expenses
  • Youthful Driver Program

Visit our review of Grange Mutual Auto Insurance Review for another car insurance review.

Bring on the savings!

We’ve done the research and have the tools to find you the best coverage for you. Let us help you discover your perfect policy.

Still paying too much?

Don't leave before you see how much we can help you save.